Epistemic status: personal, exhortatory, expressive
Jonathan Haidt has an ideology. In his academic life, he poses positive questions, but he definitely has a normative position as well. And you can see this most clearly in his speeches to young people, which are sermons on Haidtism.
Here is an example.
In it, he contrasts “Coddle U” with “Strengthen U,” two archetypal colleges. He’s clearly arguing in favor of psychological resilience, and against fragility. Let’s leave aside the question of whether feminists and other activists are actually oversensitive weenies, and whether trigger warnings are actually coddling, and engage with his main point, that it is better not to be an oversensitive weenie.
Haidt seems to see this as self-evident. The emotionally weak are to be mocked; the emotionally strong are to be respected.
I don’t find it as obvious.
Fragility can have a certain charm. Sensitive, romantic, tender spirits can be quite…
View original post 1,853 more words